Skip to content
WK LegalIndependent Legal Advice

Independent legal advice

What an independent legal advice certificate contains, and who accepts it

Clients are frequently told a solicitor needs to 'certify' something, without being told why, or what has to be in the certificate for it to be worth anything. Here is what the requirement is actually for.

Why a certificate is asked for at all

The certificate is the lender's or transaction solicitor's evidence that independent advice actually happened. It is not a formality tacked onto the end of the appointment — producing it is the reason the appointment exists.

The leading authority is a House of Lords decision, Royal Bank of Scotland plc v Etridge (No 2) [2001] UKHL 44, heard together with seven similar appeals. It held that where a lender is on notice that a guarantee or mortgage may have been procured by one party's influence over another — most often between spouses or partners, though the principle is not limited to that relationship — the lender must see that the person giving the guarantee has taken advice from a solicitor acting for them alone, and must obtain written confirmation that this happened. A lender that skips this step risks the security being challenged later and found unenforceable.

That is the whole of it from the lender's side. The certificate is not a judgment on whether the advice was good, or a guarantee that the person signing fully agreed with it. It confirms that independent advice took place, from a solicitor with nothing to gain from saying so if it did not.

What gets recorded, and when

The certificate is the shortest of three documents a properly conducted appointment produces. The Law Society's guidance, developed in response to Etridge, describes the advice itself being recorded in a full attendance note made at the time, and then confirmed in a letter sent to the client promptly after the meeting.

If the advice were ever challenged — by the person who received it, or by someone else affected by the transaction — it is the attendance note and the letter that would be examined, not the certificate. The certificate exists for the lender's file. The note and the letter exist to show, if it ever matters, what was actually discussed.

What the certificate itself usually says

Wording varies between lenders, but a certificate of this kind typically confirms the following:

  • The identity of the person who received the advice, checked by the solicitor
  • That the solicitor acts only for that person, and not for the lender, the borrower or anyone else connected with the transaction
  • That the document was explained, including its effect and the material risks of signing it
  • That the person had the opportunity to ask questions and raise concerns before deciding whether to proceed
  • That the signature was given in the solicitor's presence, or witnessed in a manner the lender accepts
  • The date the advice was given

Why there is no single standard certificate

Unlike some solicitor documents, there is no single prescribed national form for an independent legal advice certificate. Banks and building societies generally issue their own version, and UK Finance's Mortgage Lenders' Handbook sets out, lender by lender, when independent advice is required and the form it expects the confirmation to take.

A solicitor acting on a guarantee, consent form or security document is usually required to use the certificate the particular lender or transaction solicitor has issued, rather than a generic one assembled independently. This is also why the required requirements are checked before the appointment is booked, not after the advice has been given — a certificate produced on the wrong template, however thorough the advice behind it, may not be the document the lender actually asked for.

Who actually accepts it

Most mainstream lenders will accept a certificate from any independent, appropriately qualified solicitor, provided it is given in the form, or substantially the form, they require. A minority go further, specifying a face-to-face meeting rather than a remote one, or wording the solicitor must adopt rather than adapt.

This is why the requirement is treated as a question to resolve before booking, rather than an assumption to make afterwards. The useful first step, where a lender or transaction solicitor has set out what it needs, is to send that requirement over for review before the appointment is fixed.

If a certificate is not accepted

Occasionally a lender declines a certificate — most often because it was given on the wrong form, or because something about the solicitor's position did not meet the independence the lender required. The usual remedy is for the advice to be given again, correctly, rather than for the rejection to be disputed.

The practical consequence is delay rather than any loss of the advice already given, since the appointment itself was not wasted. It is simply the outcome the preliminary check before booking is designed to avoid.

Before you book

Worth having to hand before the appointment is arranged:

  • The document requiring the advice
  • Any written requirements from the lender or transaction solicitor, including their own certificate template if one has been issued
  • Whether the lender has specified a face-to-face meeting or will accept a remote appointment
  • The deadline, and who is chasing it
  • Photographic identification and proof of address

This article is general information. It is not advice on your matter, it cannot take account of your circumstances, and the law changes. If you have been asked to sign something, take advice on the document in front of you.

Need advice on your own document?

Send it across with whatever you have been told about it, and we will confirm whether we can assist.