Skip to content
WK LegalIndependent Legal Advice

Personal guarantees

Deed or simple contract: what kind of guarantee have you actually signed?

The heading on the document usually just says 'guarantee'. Whether it was signed as a deed or as a simple written contract is rarely explained, and it changes both what the lender had to give you in return and how long the lender can wait before enforcing it.

A guarantee is not just a guarantee

Personal guarantee documents routinely use that heading regardless of how they are executed, so directors tend to assume the form does not matter. It does. Most personal guarantees used by banks and commercial lenders are executed as deeds rather than as ordinary written contracts, and the difference affects how long your exposure lasts and what, if anything, the lender had to give you for your promise.

This is not a drafting formality to skim past. It is a deliberate choice made by the lender's lawyers, and it is worth understanding before you sign rather than after a demand arrives.

How to tell which one you have signed

A guarantee signed as a simple contract only has to satisfy one formality. Under the Statute of Frauds 1677, a guarantee cannot be enforced unless it is evidenced in writing and signed by the guarantor or by someone the guarantor has authorised to sign on their behalf. No witness is required, and no particular wording.

A deed has to clear a higher bar. Look for the document describing itself as a deed, for wording such as 'executed as a deed' or 'signed and delivered as a deed', and for a witness block beside your signature. If someone else has signed, printed their name and given their address next to yours, you have signed a deed.

What a deed actually requires

Under section 1(3) of the Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1989, an individual's deed is validly executed only if it is signed in the presence of a witness who attests the signature, and the document is then delivered as a deed: treated by the person signing it as taking effect, rather than simply signed and put in a drawer.

Both steps matter. A deed that is signed and witnessed but never delivered is not yet binding, which is why some guarantees state expressly that they are delivered, and take effect, on the date signed.

The witness should be someone independent of the transaction who is actually present when you sign, and who could confirm that fact if it were ever challenged. A guarantee that needed a witness and did not get one can be open to challenge, which is not something worth discovering only after you have relied on it being binding.

Why lenders ask for a deed rather than a simple contract

Two reasons explain the preference. The first is consideration. An ordinary contract needs something given in exchange for the promise made. A guarantee signed at the same time as the facility is agreed can usually point to the lender's advance of funds as that consideration, but one signed later — added as an afterthought, or demanded when a facility is varied — often has nothing to point to. A deed removes the problem, because a deed is binding without consideration at all.

The second is time. Under the Limitation Act 1980, a claim on a simple contract must be brought within six years of the cause of action accruing; a claim on a deed has twelve. A lender that may not need to call on a guarantee for years after the facility is drawn gains considerably more room to do so by using a deed.

What this means for you

The limitation period runs from the point the guarantee becomes enforceable against you — typically when the lender makes a formal demand — not from the date you signed it. If the underlying debt is called in eight years after you signed a deed of guarantee, the lender can usually still pursue you. The same claim under a simple contract guarantee could already be out of time.

This is not a reason to resist signing a deed, which is the standard form and will usually be presented to you as given rather than offered as a choice. It is a reason to treat the guarantee as a long-dated commitment rather than a short-term formality, and to keep a copy somewhere you can find it years later, since the lender's ability to enforce it does not expire quickly.

Before you sign

A short list of what is worth checking:

  • Whether the document describes itself as a deed, and whether a witness block is included
  • Whether a witness independent of the transaction will be available when you sign
  • Whether the guarantee states the date it takes effect and is treated as delivered
  • Whether the guarantee was requested alongside the facility or added some time afterwards
  • How long the guarantee itself lasts, as distinct from how long a claim on it can be brought

This article is general information. It is not advice on your matter, it cannot take account of your circumstances, and the law changes. If you have been asked to sign something, take advice on the document in front of you.

Need advice on your own document?

Send it across with whatever you have been told about it, and we will confirm whether we can assist.